- While profits may have slumped for UBS, we expect profits in the next few quarters to be bolstered by the increase in net interest income from rising rates
- UBS has a CET 1 ratio of 14.4%, much higher than their CET 1 guidance of 13%
- We prefer AT1s with higher reset spreads due to lower extension risk
- Based on our estimates, calling back the UBS 5.875% Perpetual Corp (SGD) and replacing it with a similar NC5 AT1 perp still remains economical for UBS
- We maintain our recommendation of UBS 5.875% Perpetual Corp (SGD)
Asian perpetual bonds saw a fall in prices after the flip flop decision from Heungkuk Life in calling its perpetual bonds. Additional tier 1 (“AT1”) bonds face higher extension risks due to rising interest rates and widening spreads. We believe, in the SGD AT1 space, UBS will still be able to call its SGD AT1s on its call date.
3Q22 financial highlights
In the third quarter ending 30 September 2022 (“3Q22”), UBS recorded USD 2.32b in operating profit before tax, a 19% decrease from the year prior. Net fee and commission income fell by 20% year-over-year (“yoy”) to USD 4.48b. Negative market performance and fall in client activity resulted in the fall in net fee and commission income.
Global Wealth Management (“GWM”) benefited from the rise in interest rates and revenues increased by 20% to USD 1.63b. Investment Bank (“IB”) division continues to be affected by lower capital market activity as IB revenues fell 5% to USD 1.36b. On the other hand, Derivatives & Solutions revenues improved by USD 68m due to elevated market volatility.
Based on sensitivity estimates by UBS, it is estimated that a parallel shift in yield curves by +100 basis points may result in an increase in net interest income by USD 1.6b in GWM and P&C banking.
While profits may have slumped for UBS, we expect profits in the next few quarters to be bolstered by the increase in net interest income from rising rates. IB is expected to continue to experience a downward trend in profits from the slowdown in capital markets.
Credit profile
UBS has a strong credit and solvency profile. In 3Q22, UBS has a CET 1 ratio of 14.4%, much higher than their CET 1 guidance of 13%. This results in a buffer of ~13bn over its regulatory CET 1 requirement of 10.3%. In Table 1, UBS has one of the highest CET 1 buffer among other EU banks. Its liquidity coverage ratio is also strong at 162.7% while net stable funding ratio was at 120.4%, both above regulatory requirements of 100%.
Table 1:CET 1 ratios of EU Banks
|
Bank |
CET1 ratio (as of 3Q22) |
CET 1 requirement |
CET1 buffer (bps) |
|
Barclays PLC |
13.8 |
10.9 |
290 |
|
BNP Paribas SA |
12.1 |
9.4 |
270 |
|
Commerzbank AG |
13.8 |
9.4 |
440 |
|
Credit Suisse Group AG |
12.6 |
10.2 |
240 |
|
Deutsche Bank AG |
13.3 |
10.4 |
290 |
|
HSBC Holdings PLC |
13.4 |
10 |
340 |
|
Lloyds Banking Group PLC |
15 |
10.2 |
480 |
|
Societe Generale SA |
13.1 |
9.27 |
383 |
|
Standard Chartered PLC |
13.7 |
10.2 |
350 |
|
UBS Group AG |
14.4 |
10.2 |
420 |
|
Source: Bloomberg Finance L.P., iFAST compilations. Data as of 14 Nov 2022. |
|||
AT1s and their extension risk
AT1 bonds from banks face higher extension risks. Most AT1s have a reset feature embedded in the notes where the bond will reset at the prevailing benchmark rate plus an additional spread. When interest rates rise, this makes cost of borrowings rise. Benchmark rates have risen substantially the past year, resulting in higher reset rates for AT1s. As credit spreads widen for banks, their cost of issuing new debt will be much higher as well.
We have noted that the cost of issuing new NC5 AT1 bonds will be much higher than letting the notes reset. This would explain why we have seen some non-calls from issuers in 2022. Asian perpetual bonds took a hit after Korean life insurer, Heungkuk Life, reversed its decision to call its perpetual bonds on its call date on 9 Nov 2022. This may set a precedent for more non-calls from financial institutions to come, increasing extension risks in AT1s.
In the EU AT1 space, the European Central Bank have been flirting with the idea of limiting the possibility to call AT1 bonds if it is uneconomical for the bank. If implemented would mean that AT1 bonds can only be replaced with a cheaper AT1 instrument at a lower coupon rate. This would allow banks to miss their call dates and not have any reputational consequences. However, Credit Suisse’s redemption of its CS 7.125% Perpetual Corp (USD) in July was largely uneconomical as it replaced the 7.125% perps with the CS 9.750% Perpetual Corp (USD) when the 7.125% perps could have reset to a coupon of 8.2%. The implementation of this regulation would result in less calls for AT1s on their call date. However, we have seen largely the past year that most banks have gone ahead and called their AT1s even though it was uneconomic for them.
In the SGD AT1 space, 2 bonds had their call date in 2022 - HSBC 4.700% Perpetual Corp (SGD) and BAERVX 5.750% Perpetual Corp (SGD), both of which were redeemed on their call date. Looking ahead, there are 7 AT1 bonds callable throughout 2023 and 2024. In Table 2, we estimated the cost of issuing a new AT1 bond, where we used the current I-spread + the indicative 5Y swap offer rate to estimate the coupon rate of issuing a new AT1 bond. We then compared the estimated cost of refinancing with a new AT1 bond with their respective indicative reset coupons. Only 2 AT1 bonds are economical for the issuer to call - STANLN 5.375% Perpetual Corp (SGD) and UBS 5.875% Perpetual Corp (SGD). Spreads and interest rates have widened, resulting in the cost of issuing new AT1 bonds to be higher.
Considering that spreads have widened alongside with higher swap rates, we prefer AT1s with higher reset spreads as it will lower extension risk as it will be more economical for the issuer to call back its AT1 bonds on its first call date.
Table 2: SGD AT1s callable in 2023-2024, only 2 are economical
|
Bond |
First call date |
Current I-spread (bps) |
Reset rate |
Swap rate (%) |
Indicative Reset coupon (%) (a) |
Estimated cost of issuing new AT1 (%) (b) |
Estimated additional cost of issuing new AT1 (b-a) |
|
CS 5.625% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
6 Jun 2024 |
619 |
5Y SOR+3.77 |
3.59 |
7.41 |
9.83 |
2.42% |
|
UBS 4.850% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
4 Sep 2024 |
339 |
5Y SOR+3.37 |
3.59 |
7.01 |
7.03 |
0.02% |
|
SOCGEN 6.125% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
16 Apr 2024 |
481 |
5Y SOR+4.21 |
3.59 |
7.85 |
8.45 |
0.60% |
|
STANLN 5.375% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
3 Oct 2024 |
264 |
5Y SOR+3.68 |
3.59 |
7.32 |
6.28 |
-1.04% |
|
UBS 5.875% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
28 Nov 2023 |
261 |
5Y SOR+3.61 |
3.59 |
7.25 |
6.25 |
-1.00% |
|
HSBC 5.000% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
24 Sep 2023 |
282 |
5Y SOR+2.67 |
3.59 |
6.31 |
6.46 |
0.15% |
|
OCBCSP 4.000% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
24 Aug 2023 |
185 |
5Y SOR+1.81 |
3.59 |
5.45 |
5.49 |
0.04% |
|
Source: Bloomberg Finance L.P., iFAST compilations. Data as of 16 Nov 2022. |
|||||||
Recommendation
Comparing to other comparable SGD AT1 bonds, we think the UBS 5.875% Perpetual Corp (SGD) offers the best value in terms of years to maturity as well as its yield to next call (“YTC”). As of 16 Nov 2022, the UBS 5.875% Perpetual Corp (SGD) has an indicative YTC of 6.13% with 1.03 years to maturity. At an indicative ask price of 99.72, it has a current yield of 5.89%. If not called on 28 Nov 2023, the perp will reset at the prevailing 5Y SOR + 360.5 basis points (“bps”).
Its short time to its next call date makes the perp less volatile to interest rate movements. The higher initial spread of 360.5 bps compared to the UBS 4.850% Perpetual Corp (SGD)’s initial spread of 337 bps, provides more incentive for UBS to call the bonds back on their call date. As per our estimates, calling back the UBS 5.875% Perpetual Corp (SGD) and replacing it with a similar NC5 AT1 perp still remains economical for UBS.
Considering that spreads have widened alongside with higher swap rates, we prefer AT1s with higher reset spreads as it will lower extension risk as it will be more economical for the issuer to call back its AT1 bonds on its first call date. Thus, we maintain our recommendation of UBS 5.875% Perpetual Corp (SGD).
Table 3: Relative valuation of comparable SGD AT1 bonds
|
Bond Name |
Issuer |
First Call Date |
Years to First Call date |
Ask price |
Yield to Next Call (%) |
|
CS 5.625% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
Credit Suisse Group AG |
6 Jun 2024 |
1.56 |
76.54 |
24.75 |
|
UBS 4.850% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
UBS Group AG |
4 Sep 2024 |
1.80 |
96.88 |
6.73 |
|
SOCGEN 6.125% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
Societe Generale SA |
16 Apr 2024 |
1.42 |
93.44 |
11.27 |
|
STANLN 5.375% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
Standard Chartered PLC |
3 Oct 2024 |
1.88 |
98.97 |
5.97 |
|
UBS 5.875% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
UBS Group AG |
28 Nov 2023 |
1.03 |
99.72 |
6.13 |
|
HSBC 5.000% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
HSBC Holdings PLC |
24 Sep 2023 |
0.85 |
99.09 |
6.14 |
|
OCBCSP 4.000% Perpetual Corp (SGD) |
Oversea-Chinese Banking Corp Ltd |
24 Aug 2023 |
0.77 |
99.11 |
5.16 |
|
Source: Bloomberg Finance L.P., iFAST compilations. Data as of 16 Nov 2022. |
|||||
Declaration: For specific disclosure, at the time of publication of this report, IFPL (via its connected and associated entities) holds a position in CS 5.625% Perpetual Corp (SGD), UBS 5.875% Perpetual Corp (SGD), HSBC 6.500% 20May2024 Corp (GBP), HSBC 4.375% 23Nov2026 Corp (USD), OCBCSP 3.900% Perpetual Corp (SGD) and the analyst who produced this report holds a NIL position in the abovementioned securities.
Our podcast series, Yield Hunters, is available on Spotify, iTunes Podcasts and Google Podcasts. We share our thoughts on new bond issues and hold discussions on the fixed income space. Listen to our latest episode below and follow us!


















