Idea of the week: High coupon and over 6% yield for this global commodity trader

Trafigura Group had a strong year in 2023. We find its USD bond attractive, especially for yield hunters.

Author Pic
Published on 29 May 2024 • 10 min(s) read
Featured Image
Receive first-hand news on the latest bond issues, credit updates and special events when you join us on our Telegram channel at https://t.me/bondsupermart!

  • Trafigura reported record profits of USD 7.4B in FY23, up 5% YoY from USD 7.0B in FY22 as all core divisions saw robust financial performance.
  • We remain positive and expect Trafigura’s profits to be anchored moving forward as the macro backdrop improves while structural trends support key divisions.
  • Credit profile remains stable and healthy. Debt metrics have also improved since Covid times while cashflow generation and liquidity position remain robust.
  • We like TRAFIG 5.875% 23Sep2025 Corp (USD) for its attractive indicative yield of 6.7% and high coupons.

Trafigura Group Pte. Ltd. (“Trafigura”) was established in 1993 and is one of the world’s largest suppliers of minerals, metals and energy.  Trafigura sources, stores, transports and delivers a range of commodities to clients globally. The Group’s main business divisions are:

  • The Energy segment is engaged in oil and petroleum products, which includes the sourcing, provision, and storage of oil, at all stages from crude to finished products. The segment is also involved in trading and investing in power and renewable energy.

  • The Metals and Minerals segment trades copper, lead, zinc, aluminum, nickel, cobalt, iron ore, and coal in all forms. The segment is involved in the mining, smelting, blending, warehousing, and the transportation of metals and minerals. 

In FY23, the Energy segment contributed to 70% of the group’s revenue while Metals and Minerals made up the remaining 30% of the group’s revenue. While Trafigura is domiciled in Singapore, the Group’s operations span across the globe with majority of its revenues generated in Asia, Australia, and Europe.

FY23 Financial Highlights


For the full year financial results ending 30 September 2023 (“FY23”), Trafigura reported record profits of USD 7.4B, up 5% YoY from USD 7.0B in FY22. Underlying EBITDA also climbed by 5% YoY to USD 12.7B from USD 12.1B in FY22. This was largely attributed to a 44% YoY increase in services revenue across all core divisions as the turbulent commodity markets in 1H23 sparked greater demand for the Group’s services in the same period. Operating expenses fell by -25% YoY, which also contributed to higher profits, as lower average commodity prices resulted in a drop in input costs.

In FY23, Trafigura’s revenue dropped -23% YoY to USD 244.3B, from USD318.5B in 2022, reflecting lower average commodity prices. However, the total traded volume for the underlying commodities remained largely unchanged from the prior year. On a positive note, oil volumes have stabilised after the termination of long-term contracts from Russian energy products in light of the international sanctions which took effect in May 2022.

Chart 1: Trafigura hit record profits again in FY23 despite a drop in revenue

The Group recorded a total impairment of USD 539M for fixed and financial assets in FY23, down from USD 639M a year prior. In FY23, the Group recognised three major impairments - USD 257M from Nyrstar’s operations in Australia, USD 126M from Puma Energy in the US, and USD 129M reflecting provisions made for credit exposures (Nyrstar is engaged in critical minerals product and Puma Energy is a multinational mid- and downstream oil company. Both are subsidiaries of the Group).

In terms of divisional performance, all core segments had a strong year. Trafigura’s energy division exhibited robust growth in FY23 with operating profit of USD 11.1B before depreciation and amortisation. This reflected a 10% YoY growth as new regulations and changes in global trade flow continued to drive demand for Trafigura’s services.

Trafigura’s Metals and Minerals segment delivered an operating profit of USD 1.6B before depreciation and amortisation. The division recorded a one-off exceptional charge of USD 578M write-off loss from a fraud against Trafigura. Excluding the charge, the operating profit would be USD 2.2B, above the past three-year average as highlighted by management. The strong performance was underpinned by heightened demand from the global energy-transition movement. 

Chart 2: Trafigura’s operating division continued to exhibit robust growth in FY23

Another year of record profit in FY24?


Trafigura’s business model benefits from volatility in commodities markets and supply chain disruption. As a global commodity trade, the Group possesses expertise in solving supply-demand disconnects in volatile commodity markets, which becomes highly valued by customers. Trafigura also operates as a global supply chain manager and, in periods of higher supply chain pressures, there is greater demand for the Group’s expertise.

With Trafigura expecting a return to normalise conditions for commodity markets in 2024 as supply chain disruption and price volatility ease, we think record profits are unlikely to be replicated. That said, we remain positive and expect Trafigura’s earnings to be supported moving forward. The macro narrative which has been a headwind for commodity prices last year has improved. Recession talks have given way to resilient economic growth, reinforcing the ‘soft-landing’ narrative and supporting average commodity prices which can uplift the Group’s revenue.

In terms of division, the outlook for Trafigura’s metal and minerals business looks promising. Management expects metals demand from renewables, electrification and electric vehicle sales to spike in coming years. A recovery in economic activity moving forward, will also support demand for minerals like coal and iron ore. Meanwhile, the Group’s Gas, Power and Renewables business is emerging as a strong third pillar. While prices of gas and power softened in 2023, Trafigura expects markets to remain volatile this year, supporting demand for the Group’s services. 

Credit highlight


Leverage and debt metrics


Trafigura had a total debt of USD 34.4b in FY23, falling from USD 39.3B in FY22. A large exposure (USD 25.1b or 73%) of total debt was to short term loans and borrowings. To better measure the Group’s true indebtedness, Trafigura reports an adjusted debt figure as well, which primarily adjusts the gross debt figure above with (i) cash; (ii) readily-marketable inventories; and (iii) receivables securitisation debt.

In FY23, Trafigura’s adjusted debt was -USD 7.1B, largely unchanged from the previous year - A negative adjusted net debt position reflects the greater value of liquid assets over debt. The Group’s adjusted debt has improved with net debt turning negative since FY21, reflecting less aggressive financial leverage in recent years.

This was reflected by an improvement in debt metrics over the past few years. Adjusted net debt to equity was estimated to be at a healthy - 0.43x as of end-Sep ‘23, in line with -0.47x recorded in end-Sep ’22 (negative ratio is a reflection of the negative adjusted debt, explained above) (chart 3). Trafigura’s medium-term target is to maintain a low ratio up to a maximum of 1x, suggesting prudence in managing financial leverage.

Meanwhile, corporate debt to EBITDA ratio was also estimated to be at a healthy -0.6x as of end-Sep ’23, improving from -0.1x as of end-Sep ’22 (negative ratio is a reflection of the negative corporate debt, suggesting the greater value of liquid assets over corporate debt) (chart 4). The improvement was primarily due to lower negative corporate debt as cash generation improved in FY23 (more below). 

The Group sees corporate debt to EBITDA ratio as a more relevant ratio for senior unsecured creditors. First, it focuses on debt which is repaid by EBITDA generation. Second, corporate debt (which differs from adjusted debt) accounts for the excess of trade receivables over payables which would be available to senior creditors in the case of liquidation.

Trafigura’s EBITDA interest coverage ratio moderated to 3.3x in FY23, from 5.3x in FY22 as interest expense climbed after the steep rate hikes last year (Chart 4). However, we recognise the FY22 ratio as historically strong, given the record FY22 EBITDA and relatively low interest expense. We see the moderation in coverage as a normalisation rather than a weakening. In fact, robust FY23 EBITDA provides more than sufficient coverage of interest expense (3.3x), even with benchmark rates at a potential peak.

Chart 3: Adjusted debt and adjusted gearing ratio have improved after FY20 and remained healthy   

Chart 4: Other key debt ratios like coverage and corporate debt/ EBITDA remains healthy    

Cashflow and Liquidity


To understand Trafigura’s underlying cash flow generation, we measure the Group’s operating free cash flow (“FCF”) generation (defined as operating cashflow before working capital changes subtracting the net cash used in investing activities as well as financial obligations like net interest, tax, and dividend paid). Working capital is excluded as it can be driven from fluctuations in commodity prices and volume which in turn causes swings in cash flow generated. Also, these changes often have little impact on underlying performance as price risk is hedged and short-term financing is used to finance outflows. 

Trafigura’s operating FCF generation was estimated to be USD 8.2B in FY23, improving from the USD 8.1B recorded in the previous year (chart 5). Operating FCF generation has been positive over the past eight years, following a period of intensive capital investment that ended in 2015, and has also surged in FY22 following record profits. We think this reflects Trafigura’s ability and commitment to consistently generate positive cash flow.

Chart 5: Operating FCF generation has improved greatly and remain robust

Trafigura has improved and continues to maintain a robust liquidity position in FY23. Total credit lines reached USD 75.4B, provided by 150 banks globally. The Group has a liquidity reserve of USD 14.0B as of end-Sep ’23, reflecting the same-day access to available cash in liquidity funds (USD 7.5B) and unutilised committed corporate credit facilities (USD 6.5B). This is sufficient to cover a majority of Trafigura’s short-term debt (USD 25.1B). We are not concerned with the shortfall given the Group’s strong cash generation and ability to secure funding (estimated USD9.2B worth of financing secured in FY23). 

The commodity trading business tends to be dominated by privately owned companies. These companies often are not compelled to disclose financial information and are not strictly regulated. As such, legal issues can be common in the industry. In late March, Trafigura has pleaded guilty to bribery charges in Brazil. The Group has set aside a provision of USD 127.0M to pay the fine (USD 80.4M) and forfeiture (USD 46.5M). While the additional provision will be recognised in FY24, we think the amount is unlikely to hurt the Group’s credit profile.

Recommendation


Table 1: Trafigura’s fixed rate bonds

Bond name

Issuer

Currency

Years to maturity / next call

Ask price

Yield to maturity / next call (%)

TRAFIG 5.875% 23Sep2025 Corp (USD)

Trafigura Funding SA

USD

1.32

98.80

6.72

TRAFIG 3.875% 02Feb2026 Corp (EUR)

Trafigura Funding SA

EUR

1.68

97.97

5.15

Source: Bloomberg Finance L.P., iFAST compilations. Data as of 24 May 2023.


Overall, Trafigura’s credit profile remains stable and healthy. The group remains prudent on financial leverage and debt metrics have also improved since Covid times. The strong generation of cashflow and maintenance of robust liquidity position will likely remain a focus of the Group moving forward, supporting the sustainability of its credit health. A supportive earnings outlook further adds to our positive view on the Group’s credit profile.

Among its fixed rate bonds, we like the TRAFIG 5.875% 23Sep2025 Corp (USD) and recommend the bond for investors seeking for higher yields and/or coupons. The USD fixed-rate bond looks more attractive when compared to the TRAFIG 3.875% 02Feb2026 Corp (EUR). The bond has a short 1.3 years to maturity while offering an attractive indicative yield to maturity of 6.7% and near coupon of near 6.0%. 

After an extended period of credit spread compression for Trafigura’s bonds, spreads have ticked up recently in February (The USD bond has a Z-spread of 163bps as of 28 May). We do not see this as a reflection of higher credit risk for the Group but rather an opportunity for higher yields and expect spreads to compress moving forward, as what credit markets have undergone lately. 

Declaration: For specific disclosure, at the time of publication of this report, IFPL (via its connected and associated entities) holds a NIL position and the analyst who produced this report hold a NIL position in the abovementioned securities.


Our podcast series, Yield Hunters, is available on Spotify, iTunes Podcasts and Google Podcasts. We share our thoughts on new bond issues and hold discussions on the fixed income space. Listen to our latest episode below and follow us!    


All Contents here in do not constitute financial advice or formal recommendation and must not be relied upon as such. Bondsupermart and its Information Providers are not giving or purporting to give or representing or holding ourselves out as giving personalised financial, investment, tax, legal and other professional advice. Please read our full Terms and Conditions section on the website

Facebook Comments